The following is from a regular column by Nobuyuki Kaji, Professor Emeritus of Osaka University, published in today's Sankei Shimbun under the title "Differences between Reports and Papers."
It is a must-read not only for Japanese citizens but for people worldwide.
As an older man, I am approaching the end of my life.
The decline of the five senses is severe.
In the old days, when I heard one, my brain would instantly know ten. Right now, whether I listen to that one or not, I'm all the same.
All will sink into the sea of oblivion.
Sorry for the bad news.
Either way, you too.
Excuse me, excuse me; you can still go.
In any case, I'm in an old age of oblivion and watch TV daily.
In that case, my lifelong habit, that is, my critical spirit, will reveal what I should have seen if I looked at it honestly.
For example, NHK's morning drama "Ranman."
The main character is a setting called Tomitaro Makino.
As you know, Makino only went to elementary school.
However, he connected with Tokyo Imperial University and was allowed to go in and out.
NHK is trying to draw various human dramas born from that.
Although I am a researcher with absolutely no connection with botany, as an older man and a Chinese philosopher, I have something in common regarding research and researcher, so I gradually came to watch this drama often.
Of course, since it's a drama, NHK is probably producing it from that standpoint, so I won't complain about that.
However, I think it would be a problem if viewers all over the country were to have an academic image of this drama that is currently being broadcast.
I want to tell you what the problem is.
There are common assessments in every field of study.
Research results are the same whether in the humanities or the sciences and always appear as printed matter.
The first decision to make about the publication is whether it is an article or a report.
The reports are rigorous research reports on individual subjects.
It is an important base material for research.
A thesis is a document that presents a new opinion as a theory based on such reports.
The above is the knowledge of researchers.
The work of Tomitaro Makino.
He left some awe-inspiring achievements, but most were reports on plants.
Of course, good reporting is of great value, but reporting is research, not discourse.
There will be times behind this.
In the Meiji and Taisho eras, the distinction between papers and reports was not strict and often confused.
It is because, at that time, "erudition and extensive knowledge" was valued.
For example, regarding the number of papers published, China currently has the most significant digit, ranking first globally.
However, the tone of the mass media is that Japan is in 36th place, even at the top of the list, the University of Tokyo.
But I dare say.
Most of the so-called Chinese papers are reports.
It is also necessary for the Chinese to see no distinction between papers and reports.
"Xunzi," it said that if you don't climb high mountains, you won't know how high the heavens are.
(Kaji Nobuyuki)
最新の画像[もっと見る]
-
National Expo 2025 Memorial Botanical Garden…Osaka’s Thousand Cherry Blossoms and 9分前
-
国立万博2025記念植物園 ― 大屋根リングと大阪の千本桜、森と四季と香の御三家 24分前
-
国立万博2025記念植物園 ― 森と四季と香の御三家 45分前
-
先日の国連についての論文の正しさが証明されている記事である 2週間前
-
ほぼ全員の方々の拍手で賛成多数で総裁選の前倒しの検討を総裁選管理委に申し送るということになった 3週間前
-
石破政権樹立で動いたあの逢沢氏だけに、執行部&逢沢氏でどんな謀りごとを巡らすか注目。 3週間前
-
文書がなくてもいいと言っていた政府関係者とそのポチはどう説明するのかねえ 3週間前
-
How the Ministry of Finance Manipulated Kan and Noda 3週間前
-
民主党の野田政権、その前の菅直人政権から「日本はギリシャになる」と菅直人氏に言わせるような紙面作りをずっと日経は行ってきたわけです。 3週間前
-
再発信!弱い政権のときは財務省の言うことをするする聞いちゃう。そして、政権は増税の踏み台になって潰れる。 3週間前