Phys. Rev. Lett.から返事

投稿論文の査読結果が戻ってきました。

経過は以下の通りです。
01Aug2014 submit
01Aug14 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
04Aug14 Acknowledgment sent to author
04Aug14 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
06Aug14 Right to publish signature received
06Aug14 Correspondence (miscellaneous) sent to author
18Aug14 Reminder to referee [others sent (not shown) at 1-2 week intervals]
18Aug14 Reminder to referee [others sent (not shown) at 1-2 week intervals]
04Aug14 18Aug14 Review request to referee; message received (not a report)
04Aug14 26Aug14 Review request to referee; report received
02Sep14 03Sep14 Reminder to referee; response received
19Aug14 03Sep14 Review request to referee; report received
04Sep14 Editorial decision and/or referee comments sent to author
レフリーの一人が辞退し、交代したため一ヶ月かかったようです。
米国東海岸から届くのか
事務的なメールは日本時間夜9時台
最終判断は朝9時台に届きました。

今回はレフリーの意見が割れました。
望みはまだありそうです。
The above manuscript has been reviewed by our referees.

The resulting reports include a critique which is sufficiently adverse
that we cannot accept your paper on the basis of material now at hand.
We append pertinent comments.

If you feel that you can overcome or refute the criticism, you may
resubmit to Physical Review Letters. With any resubmittal, please
include a summary of changes made and a brief response to all
recommendations and criticisms.

Yours sincerely,


因みにリジェクトの場合はこんな感じです。
The above manuscript has been reviewed by our referee(s).

A critique drawn from the report(s) appears below. On this basis, we
judge that the paper is not appropriate for Physical Review Letters,
but might be suitable for publication in another journal, possibly with
some revision. Therefore, we recommend that you submit your manuscript
elsewhere.

Yours sincerely,