井沢満ブログ

後進に伝えたい技術論もないわけではなく、「井沢満の脚本講座」をたまに、後はのんびりよしなしごとを綴って行きます。

SOS 英語の翻訳をお願いします

2017年10月09日 | 日記

 

「ジョージィ!」という私の原作が、イタリアでアニメ版がオンエアされたりミュージカルとして劇場で上演されていることは、お伝えしましたが現地のファンクラブの方から、英語のコメントをいただきました。

よくまぁ、私の日本語のブログを探し当てたものですが・・・・

いい大人の男性もいたり、メキシコの男の子もいたりするので驚いています。

以下がコメ欄へのコメントです。

Lady Georgie sequel (Belinda- Italian Georgie'fans Group)2017-10-08 22:41:58Hello Mr Izawa,
we are an Italian group of Lady Georgie's fans,
this is our group on facebook: https://www.facebook.com/groups/286108855194869/
We recently read his blog and we were very impressed by a post that
wrote a few years ago about the end of the manga, especially the marriage between Georgie and Arthur, and above all the fact that Abel did not die.
We would like to know some other detail about it, and since the story is thus completely open,
we would like to know if you are planning to write a sequel, surely it would be greatly appreciated by the readers.
Thank you for your attention, kind regards.
Lady Georgie's fans Group

 

以下が、私のとりあえずの答。

Thanks for your interest in the story I wrote, "Georgie!" To answer your question,my English isn't enough, so please wait a few days. lol

そして、翻訳をお願いしたいのが次の文章です。

  ・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・・

続編に関してですが、それは考えていません。一度書こうとしたことがあるのですが、書くための環境が整わず中止となりました。それから、もう随分年月が経ってしまいました。

だから書こうとしていた物語の、アイディアだけを短く述べます。

原作を読めば解るように、アベルが確実に死んだという描写はありません。
処刑の寸前に、救い出された可能性があるわけです。

だから、私が書こうとしていたのは以下です。

ジョージィとジョージィとアベルの子、そしてアーサーが暮らしているオーストラリアにアベルが突然現れるのが、物語の発端です。

ジョージィとアーサーが結婚したかしてないかも、書いていません。
2つの可能性があります。

1 結婚した

2 ジョージィは、アベル一人を思いながら、アーサーの助けを得ながら赤ん坊を育てて行く

ここまでしか、実は考えていませんでした。
私の考えでは、ジョージィは突然現れたアベルに心が揺れますが、アーサーをお父さんだと思い込んだ子供のために、アベルのほうが身を退くと思います。
ジョージィも自分の思いより、3歳となったわが子の思いのほうを尊重します。

しかし、続編はあなた方読者の造像力に委ねているので、あなた達が好きなように物語を考えてください。

私はもうすっかり忘れているのですが、ジョージィとアベルの子に私は名前をつけていましたっけ? もし、つけてなかったら、あなたの好きな名前を考えてください。

ちなみに、コミック版ではページの制約で入りきれなかったエピソードを一つ、教えましょう。

ジョージィとロエルの再会のシーンですが、あの時のロエルは実は貴婦人相手のジゴロに身を落としています。

残酷すぎますか?

Grazie davvero!!

 

 ----------------------------------------------------

上記の翻訳ボランティア、よろしくお願いします。

私の下手っぴ英語で書けなくはないのですが、どうせならきちんと思いを伝えたく・・・。

⇒ 早速頂戴しました!!

「流るる雲」さん、ありがとうございます。

 

以下 訳文 +日本の読者さんの感想文

 

Dear Lady Georgie’s Fan Group,

Thank you very much again for your demonstrated enthusiasm about one of my works.
Currently, I have no plan to write a sequel to Lady Georgie. Actually, I once tried to write a sequel quite a while ago, but, due to circumstances out of my control, I could not complete it as I wished.

For your interest, I would like to briefly share some ideas that I nurtured and held for a possible sequel.

As you could tell from the original story of Lady Georgie, nothing implies the determined death of Adbel, which could be optionally interpreted as that he might have been saved right before his execution.

With this in my mind, I was going to write a story as:

The story starts with a scene that Abel abruptly comes into a place in Australia where Georgie, the child of Georgie and Abel, and Arthur live together.

Again, in the original story, nothing is specifically mentioned about marriage of Georgie and Arthur. You could think of two possibilities:
1. They got married.
2. Georgie would raise her baby by herself getting support from Arthur, keeping a special and dedicated space only for Arthur in her mind for good.

In fact, these are the only ideas I had.

I now think that Georgie will lose her composure when she unexpectedly sees Abel, but, Abel will decide to withdraw himself and leave her eventually for the sake of Georgie’s child who believes that his/her father is Arthur without any doubt. Georgie also will respect her child who turned three years old more than her affective attachment to Abel.

This is just one idea for a sequel, and I would like to leave the choice to creativity of readers. I also would like to encourage you to develop a story as you like and feel comfortable.

I have to tell you that I do not remember if I gave a name to the child of Georgie and Abel. Does anyone remember? If no name has been given, please pick a name for the child.

Lastly, I would like to share one episode which could not be included as a part of the comic version of story because of the limited pages.

It is about the scene where Georgie and Roel came across each other again. To tell the truth, Roel had abandoned his moral compass and became a gigolo to serve noblewomen at that time.

Do you think his fate was too cruel?

Also, I would like to refer you to a comment from a viewer, YUNI, of my blog:

Hello, Mr. Izawa,

Please allow me to give you my excuse of not posting my comment for long since last time.
I am very happy now because early this morning (in Japan time) I got a chance to catch a glimpse of a potential sequel of the story, and I would like to say thank you to Georgie’s Fan Club in Italy for asking such a great question.

I have been longing for a sequel of Georgie for more than thirty years. I am reassuring myself that we are now in such a wonderful era to be able to instantly access to a scenario plotted and directly shared by the author himself!

“I now think that Georgie will lose her composure when she unexpectedly sees Abel, but, Abel will decided to will withdraw himself and leave her eventually for the sake of Georgie’s child who believes that his/her father is Arthur without any doubt. Georgie also will respect her child who turned three years old more than her affective attachment to Abel.”

I could not think of any more compelling options than Abel not losing his life, which completely wins my heart and mind. Knowing that you allow us to imagine the subsequent story, I am now happy in tears.

My version of story would be like this:

When Abel Jr. (the child of Abel) is around fourteen years old, his/her life gets endangered, then, either Abel or Arthur saves Abel Jr., sacrificing his life. Abel Jr. speaks to the man who is dying in his/her arms and tells that he/she knew that the dying man is/is not his/her biological father. Also, Abel Jr. says that he/she has recognized genuine fatherhood from both Abel and Arthur. After hearing that, the man in Jr.’s arms appreciates all what has been done by the other man (either Abel or Arthur) for Abel Jr. who has grown up as a strong and compassionate child.

This morning, I indulged myself in such delusion and started crying since I was so moved... Mr. Izawa, I greatly appreciate your thoughtfulness.

I wish you could share your idea with the fans in Italy at an earliest occasion. I am very sorry that I cannot help you for translation of your feedback while I can only wish you things go well for you and your fan.

I understand that you have no plan to write a sequel of Georgie and look forward to your new dramas.


Grazie davvero!!

以下、久々にイタリア版ジョージィ関連の動画を見てみたら、ロエル役の人の歌の録音風景がありました。

Georgie il Musical: Flavio Gismondi è Lowell J. Grey

 

このシーンも初見。イタリア語は解りませんが、自分で書いたストーリーなので
意味は解ります・・・・

IL TANGO DEL DESTINO - Live Teatro Orione

 なんで、この物語がとりわけイタリアで好まれるのか(他の欧州数か国でも出版されたり、アニメのオンエアがあったのに)、日本よりイタリアでセミ古典化されそうな予感・・・・。

映画化してくれないかな・・・・。


10 コメント

コメント日が  古い順  |   新しい順
ご参考にしていただければ幸いです。 (流るる雲)
2017-10-09 09:34:16
拙訳が、お役に立てばよいのですが...。

Dear Lady Georgie’s Fan Group,

Thank you very much again for your demonstrated enthusiasm about one of my works.
Currently, I have no plan to write a sequel to Lady Georgie. Actually, I once tried to write a sequel quite a while ago, but, due to circumstances out of my control, I could not complete it as I wished.

For your interest, I would like to briefly share some ideas that I nurtured and held for a possible sequel.

As you could tell from the original story of Lady Georgie, nothing implies the determined death of Adbel, which could be optionally interpreted as that he might have been saved right before the execution.

With this in my mind, I was going to write a story as:

The story starts with a scene that Abel abruptly comes into a place in Australia where Georgie, the child of Georgie and Abel, and Arthur live together.

Again, in the original story, nothing is specifically mentioned about marriage of Georgie and Arthur, which inspired me to come up with two possibilities:
1. They got married.
2. Georgie would raise her baby by herself getting support from Arthur, keeping a special and dedicated space only for Arthur in her mind for good.
In fact, these are the only ideas I had.

I now think that Georgie will lose her composure when she unexpectedly sees Abel, but, Abel will decided to leave her eventually for the sake of Georgie’s child who believes that his/her father is Arthur without any doubt.

This is just one idea for a sequel, and I would like to leave the choice to creativity of readers. I also would like to encourage you to develop a story as you like and feel comfortable.

I have to tell you that I do not remember if I gave a name to the child of Georgie and Abel. Does anyone remember? If no name has been given, please pick a name for the child.

Lastly, I would like to share one episode which could not be included as a part of the comic version of story because of the limited pages.

It is about the scene where Georgie and Roel came across each other again. To tell the truth, Roel had abandoned his moral compass and became a gigolo to serve noblewomen at that time.

Do you think his fate is too cruel?

Grazie davvero!!




早速・・・・ (井沢満)
2017-10-09 10:00:54
長るる雲さん

ありがとうございます。

ファンクラブへのお返事として使わせて頂きます。


お手数かけました・・・・・
続編♪ (YUNI)
2017-10-09 10:13:07
井沢先生、こんにちは。
コメント欄では少々ご無沙汰しておりました。
今日は早朝からイタリアのジョージィ!ファンの皆さんのおかげで、物語の続きが少しでも知ることができたのでとても嬉しいです。

ジョージィ!の続編については、私も昭和時代から熱望していました。こういったことが先生ご本人から語られすぐに、知ることができて、なんで素晴らしい時代でしょう。

>私の考えでは、ジョージィは突然現れたアベルに心が揺れますが、アーサーをお父さんだと思い込んだ子供のために、アベルのほうが身を退くと思います。
ジョージィも自分の思いより、3歳となったわが子の思いのほうを尊重します。

アベルが生きているのなら心底納得の展開で感動です。そしてこの後は、読者の自由展開でよいとは、幸せすぎて感涙です。

私の場合は、14歳ごろのアベルジュニア(アベルの子の名)が命の危険にあったとき、アベルかアーサーのどちらかが命と引き換えにジュニアを助けて、今度こそ本当に絶命します。息を引き取る間際、ジュニアの腕の中の人物にジュニアは、本当のお父さんじゃないこと、あるいは本当のお父さんだったことを知っていたと告白します。でも二人ともアベルもアーサーの二人とももかけがえのない自分の父さんだ、と言います。それを聞いて、腕の中の人物は強くて優しい子に育ったことを一方(アベルまたはアーサー)に感謝します。

・・・なーんてことを妄想して朝から感動して泣いてしまいました。先生ありがとうございます。

イタリアのファンの皆さんにも早くお伝えできるとよいですね。私は翻訳出来ず見守るだけでお役に立てず申し訳ありません。
ジョージィ!は続編なしとのことですが、これからも先生の新作ドラマなどを楽しみにしていますね。
お返事 (井沢満)
2017-10-09 10:21:31
YUNIさん

素晴らしい、続編です。
そのままで、いいと思います。

YUNIさんの、コメントも日本のファンが考えた、続編としてどなたか訳してくださったら、ファングループに届けます。
翻訳最終版です。 (流るる雲)
2017-10-09 11:20:34
申し訳ございません、先程お送りした翻訳は、最終版ではありませんでした。よろしければ、以下、ご参照ください。

Dear Lady Georgie’s Fan Group,

Thank you very much again for your demonstrated enthusiasm about one of my works.
Currently, I have no plan to write a sequel to Lady Georgie. Actually, I once tried to write a sequel quite a while ago, but, due to circumstances out of my control, I could not complete it as I wished.

For your interest, I would like to briefly share some ideas that I nurtured and held for a possible sequel.

As you could tell from the original story of Lady Georgie, nothing implies the determined death of Adbel, which could be optionally interpreted as that he might have been saved right before his execution.

With this in my mind, I was going to write a story as:

The story starts with a scene that Abel abruptly comes into a place in Australia where Georgie, the child of Georgie and Abel, and Arthur live together.

Again, in the original story, nothing is specifically mentioned about marriage of Georgie and Arthur. You could think of two possibilities:
1. They got married.
2. Georgie would raise her baby by herself getting support from Arthur, keeping a special and dedicated space only for Arthur in her mind for good.

In fact, these are the only ideas I had.

I now think that Georgie will lose her composure when she unexpectedly sees Abel, but, Abel will decided to will withdraw himself and leave her eventually for the sake of Georgie’s child who believes that his/her father is Arthur without any doubt. Georgie also will respect her child more than her affective attachment to Abel.

This is just one idea for a sequel, and I would like to leave the choice to creativity of readers. I also would like to encourage you to develop a story as you like and feel comfortable.

I have to tell you that I do not remember if I gave a name to the child of Georgie and Abel. Does anyone remember? If no name has been given, please pick a name for the child.

Lastly, I would like to share one episode which could not be included as a part of the comic version of story because of the limited pages.

It is about the scene where Georgie and Roel came across each other again. To tell the truth, Roel had abandoned his moral compass and became a gigolo to serve noblewomen at that time.

Do you think his fate was too cruel?

Grazie davvero!!



お返事 (井沢満)
2017-10-09 11:35:38
流るる雲さん

はい、入れ替えます。


ごていねいに、ありがとうございます。
なんども厚かましくお送りしまして... (流るる雲)
2017-10-09 12:18:24
YUNI さんのコメントを翻訳し、追記しました。同時に、先程の翻訳にも最終調整を加えました。

Dear Lady Georgie’s Fan Group,

Thank you very much again for your demonstrated enthusiasm about one of my works.
Currently, I have no plan to write a sequel to Lady Georgie. Actually, I once tried to write a sequel quite a while ago, but, due to circumstances out of my control, I could not complete it as I wished.

For your interest, I would like to briefly share some ideas that I nurtured and held for a possible sequel.

As you could tell from the original story of Lady Georgie, nothing implies the determined death of Adbel, which could be optionally interpreted as that he might have been saved right before his execution.

With this in my mind, I was going to write a story as:

The story starts with a scene that Abel abruptly comes into a place in Australia where Georgie, the child of Georgie and Abel, and Arthur live together.

Again, in the original story, nothing is specifically mentioned about marriage of Georgie and Arthur. You could think of two possibilities:
1. They got married.
2. Georgie would raise her baby by herself getting support from Arthur, keeping a special and dedicated space only for Arthur in her mind for good.

In fact, these are the only ideas I had.

I now think that Georgie will lose her composure when she unexpectedly sees Abel, but, Abel will decided to will withdraw himself and leave her eventually for the sake of Georgie’s child who believes that his/her father is Arthur without any doubt. Georgie also will respect her child who turned three years old more than her affective attachment to Abel.

This is just one idea for a sequel, and I would like to leave the choice to creativity of readers. I also would like to encourage you to develop a story as you like and feel comfortable.

I have to tell you that I do not remember if I gave a name to the child of Georgie and Abel. Does anyone remember? If no name has been given, please pick a name for the child.

Lastly, I would like to share one episode which could not be included as a part of the comic version of story because of the limited pages.

It is about the scene where Georgie and Roel came across each other again. To tell the truth, Roel had abandoned his moral compass and became a gigolo to serve noblewomen at that time.

Do you think his fate was too cruel?

Also, I would like to refer you to a comment from a viewer, YUNI, of my blog:

Hello, Mr. Izawa,

Please allow me to give you my excuse of not posting my comment for long since last time.
I am very happy now because early this morning (in Japan time) I got a chance to catch a glimpse of a potential sequel of the story, and I would like to say thank you to Georgie’s Fan Club in Italy for asking such a great question.

I have been longing for a sequel of Georgie for more than thirty years. I am reassuring myself that we are now in such a wonderful era to be able to instantly access to a scenario plotted and directly shared by the author himself!

“I now think that Georgie will lose her composure when she unexpectedly sees Abel, but, Abel will decided to will withdraw himself and leave her eventually for the sake of Georgie’s child who believes that his/her father is Arthur without any doubt. Georgie also will respect her child who turned three years old more than her affective attachment to Abel.”

I could not think of any more compelling options than Abel not losing his life, which completely wins my heart and mind. Knowing that you allow us to imagine the subsequent story, I am now happy in tears.

My version of story would be like this:

When Abel Jr. (the child of Abel) is around fourteen years old, his/her life gets endangered, then, either Abel or Arthur saves Abel Jr., sacrificing his life. Abel Jr. speaks to the man who is dying in his/her arms and tells that he/she knew that the dying man is/is not his/her biological father. Also, Abel Jr. says that he/she has recognized genuine fatherhood from both Abel and Arthur. After hearing that, the man in Jr.’s arms appreciates all what has been done by the other man (either Abel or Arthur) for Abel Jr. who has grown up as a strong and compassionate child.

This morning, I indulged myself in such delusion and started crying since I was so moved... Mr. Izawa, I greatly appreciate your thoughtfulness.

I wish you could share your idea with the fans in Italy at an earliest occasion. I am very sorry that I cannot help you for translation of your feedback while I can only wish you things go well for you and your fan.

I understand that you have no plan to write a sequel of Georgie and look forward to your new dramas.


Grazie davvero!!




流るる雲さんへ (井沢満)
2017-10-09 17:14:15
こちらこそ、図々しいお願いにもかかわらず
丹念な推敲まで賜り、心より感謝申し上げます。

再度置き換えさせて頂きました。
ありがとうございます。 (YUNI)
2017-10-09 19:54:07
先生、お返事ありがとうございます。あんな適当な展開でもOKもらえて、イタリアのファンの方々へのお返事にまで使っていたけるなんて、光栄かつお恥ずかしいことこの上ないです。。そして流るる雲さん、私の極めて稚拙な日本語の翻訳にまで、お手間をとらせてしまうことになってしまって、本当に申し訳ありませんでした。心から感謝申し上げます。

それにしても、先生に物語の続きのことは本当に恐れ多くて、ここではどうにも聞けなかったのですが、イタリアのファンの方はさすがです!!。笑。
Lady Georgie sequel (Belinda- Italian Georgie'fans Group)
2017-10-23 02:55:24
Hello Mr Izawa,
thanks for your kind reply.
it was great to read your ideas about the sequel, thank you for sharing it with us!
If Rowell was a gigolo ... this fact explains very well the scene of his meeting with Georgie, and then Abel was right not to trust him! Thanks for this scoop !!!

We are the administrators of the Italian Group, and we would like to write to you privately for an idea about Lady Georgie.
As you know, Georgie is much loved here in Italy. If you wanted to know our idea, we leave you our mail so you can contact us.
We would really be very happy if we could tell you this our project.
This is our mail: lady.georgie@outlook.it
A kind greeting,
Belinda and Barbara