Saturday July 19, 2008
http://www.bangkokpost.com/190708_News/19Jul2008_news006.php
Concern over Laotian water diversion plan
Samak's pet project requires EIA study
APINYA WIPATAYOTIN
State officials and green groups have raised concern over the environmental impact Prime Minister Samak Sundaravej's multi-billion-baht water diversion project would cause, if water is diverted from a Laotian river to the northeastern farmlands.
The government has been urged to disclose the details involving the project's investment and operational costs, as well as the project site, to see if an environmental impact assessment (EIA) study is needed.
The project, which calls for the diversion of water from the Ngum river in Laos to Huay Luang in Udon Thani province, won cabinet approval on Tuesday, which also set aside a 76.8-billion-baht tunnel construction budget.
Water would be channelled from the Ngum river to Udon Thani province through a 17km-long tunnel running under the Mekong river. The distribution of water to farmlands would be done via irrigation canals and new pipelines.
Kasemsun Chinnavaso, secretary-general of the Office of Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning (Onep), said the EIA study cannot be overlooked in case the water pipeline is also designed to cut through some protected forest areas.
However, his agency, which is in charge of scrutinising EIA reports of mega-projects, has not as yet been commissioned to look into the transboundary water diversion project.
"We still have no idea from which areas it will snake through," Mr Kasemsun said. "However, what we are concerned about the most at the moment is whether the project is worth the investment. What will be the price of water per unit and who will shoulder the operational costs?"
Montree Chantawong, campaign coordinator of the Bangkok-based Towards Ecological Recovery and Regional Alliance (Terra), said there is no guarantee that Thailand would be able to use the water from Laos for free as long as there is no agreement in writing.
Even if Thailand is allowed to use its neighbour's water for free, it doesn't mean that the project would be worth the investment, he said.
"We still have to shoulder the electricity costs to operate the water pumping stations, as water would have to be pumped into reservoirs before any distribution," Mr Montree said.
He estimated that water users would have to pay 3-5 baht per unit of water under the project.
According to the group's initial survey, water pipelines will cut through over 1,000 rai of pristine forests, making the EIA study a legal requirement.
The first phase of the project will focus on the domestic diversion of water from the Huay Luang waterway to the Nonghankumphawapi natural water retention area in Udon Thani province, according to Water Resources Department chief Siripong Hungspreug. The water diversion route will cover around 143km.
The agency expects to complete the first phase of the multi-billion-baht project in 2012, while the second phase- water diversion from the Lao river to Udon Thani - will finish in 2013, with almost two billion cubic metres of water being diverted per year.
The project will benefit around 1-3 million rai of farmland in the water-starved northeast region.
http://www.bangkokpost.com/190708_News/19Jul2008_news006.php
Concern over Laotian water diversion plan
Samak's pet project requires EIA study
APINYA WIPATAYOTIN
State officials and green groups have raised concern over the environmental impact Prime Minister Samak Sundaravej's multi-billion-baht water diversion project would cause, if water is diverted from a Laotian river to the northeastern farmlands.
The government has been urged to disclose the details involving the project's investment and operational costs, as well as the project site, to see if an environmental impact assessment (EIA) study is needed.
The project, which calls for the diversion of water from the Ngum river in Laos to Huay Luang in Udon Thani province, won cabinet approval on Tuesday, which also set aside a 76.8-billion-baht tunnel construction budget.
Water would be channelled from the Ngum river to Udon Thani province through a 17km-long tunnel running under the Mekong river. The distribution of water to farmlands would be done via irrigation canals and new pipelines.
Kasemsun Chinnavaso, secretary-general of the Office of Natural Resources and Environmental Policy and Planning (Onep), said the EIA study cannot be overlooked in case the water pipeline is also designed to cut through some protected forest areas.
However, his agency, which is in charge of scrutinising EIA reports of mega-projects, has not as yet been commissioned to look into the transboundary water diversion project.
"We still have no idea from which areas it will snake through," Mr Kasemsun said. "However, what we are concerned about the most at the moment is whether the project is worth the investment. What will be the price of water per unit and who will shoulder the operational costs?"
Montree Chantawong, campaign coordinator of the Bangkok-based Towards Ecological Recovery and Regional Alliance (Terra), said there is no guarantee that Thailand would be able to use the water from Laos for free as long as there is no agreement in writing.
Even if Thailand is allowed to use its neighbour's water for free, it doesn't mean that the project would be worth the investment, he said.
"We still have to shoulder the electricity costs to operate the water pumping stations, as water would have to be pumped into reservoirs before any distribution," Mr Montree said.
He estimated that water users would have to pay 3-5 baht per unit of water under the project.
According to the group's initial survey, water pipelines will cut through over 1,000 rai of pristine forests, making the EIA study a legal requirement.
The first phase of the project will focus on the domestic diversion of water from the Huay Luang waterway to the Nonghankumphawapi natural water retention area in Udon Thani province, according to Water Resources Department chief Siripong Hungspreug. The water diversion route will cover around 143km.
The agency expects to complete the first phase of the multi-billion-baht project in 2012, while the second phase- water diversion from the Lao river to Udon Thani - will finish in 2013, with almost two billion cubic metres of water being diverted per year.
The project will benefit around 1-3 million rai of farmland in the water-starved northeast region.